One offhand remark turned a perfect toddler farm morning into a meltdown, and it exposed a parenting reflex worth resisting.

I said something dumb to my 22-month-old in the middle of a barn. We'd spent about an hour at the farm, the kind of place where you can poke your fingers through a fence to pet a goat and stand over the pigpen realizing pigs are far bigger than you remember. It was an unseasonably warm winter day. My son had shed his jacket, abandoned his stroller somewhere near the sheep, and for the first time in months, the sun was actually on our faces. He was thriving. He'd already petted a one-day-old lamb, and he'd just discovered that the barn held not one tractor, not two, but three.
Then I asked, "Do you think the cat is in here today?"
On our fall visit, a big gray cat had let him brush the tips of his fingers across its arched back. That was all it took. For days afterward he kept bringing up the cat, and I knew that if he saw it again, he'd be thrilled.
The cat was not in the barn.
The Cat Problem
Why did I bring up the cat? Ninety seconds earlier we looked like a scene from a children's picture book. Now there was only one goal in his head: find the cat. I had planted the idea, and he loves cats, especially this one. So, true to form, the cat was nowhere to be found.
The tears started quickly. Three tractors suddenly weren't enough. The baby goats were garbage. The tiny lambs he'd been delighted to pet minutes earlier didn't count for anything. Only the cat mattered.
"I don't know," I said, hoping his wails weren't drawing too much attention from the less cat-obsessed visitors. "He's probably sleeping somewhere."
"WHERE CAT," he demanded. Over and over.
I had broken my own first rule of parenting: never try to make a happy kid happier.
My friend Joanna gave me that rule. She'd picked it up from her parents, and the moment she said it, I recognized one of my biggest weaknesses. I want my son to be having a good time, and some part of me believes that if I'm not actively working to improve his time, it isn't as good as it could be.
When he was a baby and happily chewing one teether, I'd hand him a second one. He liked the dog at the park? Fine, we'd leave that park and go find one with a dozen dogs. If he was perfectly content tossing rocks into a puddle, I'd offer to find him bigger rocks that would make a bigger splash. I was always upgrading something that didn't need upgrading.
Nurturing Versus Hovering
Parents feel a real pull to fill every gap. We want to give our kids the complete package and make sure every need gets met as well as possible. That instinct is good. It's the reason we don't leave them in the woods when they cry at 4 a.m., and why we keep offering dinner even when it ends up on the floor. But the same drive can stop us from noticing when we aren't needed.
That's what "don't make a happy kid happier" does for me. It reminds me that sometimes being happy is enough. Small children live almost entirely in the present, and whatever they're doing is usually the only thing on their minds. Sure, there may be bigger, splashier rocks lying around the puddle. But the rocks already in his hand work just fine.
When I step in to improve his fun, I tell myself I'm helping. What I'm really doing is suggesting his current fun isn't good enough. Once he hears that, it often stops being good enough, even if it was perfect thirty seconds before.
What It Cost
We never found the cat. I paid for my mistake in toddler currency: a full-blown tantrum. He eventually settled down, and by the time we left the farm he was kicking his feet and chattering away in his stroller. I thought about stopping for ice cream at the gift shop, then decided against it. He was just fine without it.
Discussion
Sign in to join the discussion.